As the most isolated population center on earth and a true melting pot of cultures, the Hawaiian Islands are home to some of the world’s greatest cuisine. But in order to taste some of most mouthwatering food Hawaii has to offer, you must be willing to leave the resort areas and check out local hole in the wall joints. Case and point: this unassuming eatery on Oahu’s north shore that serves up some of the islands’ best pizza and pasta — at an affordable price, too!

Welcome to Spaghettini, a small unassuming eatery on Haleiwa’s Kamehameha Highway. If I hadn’t walked by the vibrant green building and noticed the wafting smell of freshly baked pizza dough, just as I was trying to decide what to eat for lunch that day, I may have never stopped by — and I would have been severely missing out.

Spaghettini New York Style Pizza and Pasta, Haleiwa, Hawaii/Facebook

Served on disposable plates and consumed on folding tables and chairs, Spaghettini is the definition of a Hawaiian hole-in-the-wall, but once you look past the unassuming counter-serve restaurant with open-air seating and try a slice of pizza or plate of pasta, you’ll be hooked.

Spaghettini New York Style Pizza and Pasta, Haleiwa, Hawaii/Facebook

Spaghettini is known for serving up a wide variety of scrumptious Italian dishes, from pizza and pasta to garlic bread and buffalo chicken wings.

Spaghettini New York Style Pizza and Pasta, Haleiwa, Hawaii/Facebook

Homemade sauces and dough are made using only the best available ingredients, and it shows.

Spaghettini New York Style Pizza and Pasta, Haleiwa, Hawaii/Facebook

You’ll find all sorts of pasta dishes on the menu here, including fettuccine alfredo, lasagna, chicken marinara over linguine, penne bolognese, shrimp scampi, ravioli, and — of course — spaghetti. You can also order a salad or oven-baked sandwich.

Spaghettini New York Style Pizza and Pasta, Haleiwa, Hawaii/Facebook

From your standard pizza options like cheese, pepperoni, and vegetarian to island-inspired pizzas topped with pineapple and ham, you can’t go wrong with a slice of pizza. Their spinach and garlic pizza is particularly delicious and for less than $4 a slice, this is an affordable lunch spot — especially when you see how massive a single slice is!

Spaghettini New York Style Pizza and Pasta, Haleiwa, Hawaii/Facebook

Don’t forget to order an appetizer to share with the table. From tomato brushchetta and mozzarella sticks to chicken tenders, fries, and zucchini sticks, you’ll be in food heaven at Spaghettini.

Spaghettini New York Style Pizza and Pasta, Haleiwa, Hawaii/Facebook

No matter what you order, you’ll leave Spaghettini feeling not only happy and full but excited to visit again to try all of the incredible dishes on their menu. So, what are you waiting for? Add this humble little eatery to your Hawaii dining bucket list as soon as possible.

Spaghettini New York Style Pizza and Pasta, Haleiwa, Hawaii/Facebook

Spaghettini is located at 66-200 Kamehameha Hwy. Suite B, Haleiwa, HI 96712, and is open daily from 11 a.m. to 8 p.m. For more information, visit their website or follow them on Facebook.

Spaghettini New York Style Pizza and Pasta, Haleiwa, Hawaii/Facebook

If you’re not craving pizza or pasta, consider checking out any of these other phenomenal restaurants found in Haleiwa.

OnlyInYourState may earn compensation through affiliate links in this article.