Old School Italian Sandwich Shop In Pittsburgh Sits In An Old School Building

If you grew up in the Homestead neighborhood of Pittsburgh, you’ve probably passed by the old Saint Michael’s Parochial School. Until 1965, the school educated local children. But, from 1965 until the 21st century, it sat empty, awaiting the transformation that would finally come in 2012. Today, the old school – complete with its original chalk boards – houses a delightful sandwich shop that serves sandwiches as well as other mouthwatering meals.

Look for the bright yellow sign that says “ENTER” then follow it to the Old School Italian Sandwich Shop in Homestead.

FourSquare/Old School Italian Sandwich Shop Old School Italian Sandwich Shop only accepts cash.

When you first walk through the front door, expect the nostalgia of your own school days - at the sight of the high windows and chalkboard - to wash over you.

Four Square/Old School Italian Sandwich Shop

Then, give in to your hunger as you peruse the menu, brimming with delicious dishes. Kick off your meal with a bowl of soup (when available) or a crisp salad.

Facebook/Old School Italian Sandwich Shop

Or, start by ordering one of the hearty sandwiches, such as The History Lesson, an Italian meatball sandwich so soft it’s sure to “melt in your mouth.”

FourSquare/Old School Italian Sandwich Shop

Other aptly-named sandwiches include the Learning Pig Latin (a sweet ham sandwich), and The Classic Italian.

Facebook/Old School Italian Sandwich Shop

And, if you’re in the mood for pasta, try the scrumptious pasta meal topped with a homemade meatball and paired with a fresh bun.

FourSquare/Old School Italian Sandwich Shop

Don’t forget to save room for a scrumptious dessert, such as the fresh baked vanilla cake or chocolate cake or the homemade biscotti.

Facebook/Old School Italian Sandwich Shop

Sit down to a delicious meal at this old school sandwich shop, open Tuesday through Friday from 11 a.m. to 6 p.m. and Saturday from 12 p.m. to 6 p.m.

FourSquare/Thomas R.

Old School Italian Sandwich is located 1917, 609 E. 9th Ave., Homestead, PA 15120.

Facebook/Old School Italian Sandwich Shop Click here for the official website of Old School Italian Sandwich Shop. Or, go here for Facebook.

Have you ever been to this sandwich shop in Pittsburgh? Share your experience in the comments! Then, click here to read about nine other spots that sell amazing sandwiches in the Burgh.

FourSquare/Old School Italian Sandwich Shop

Old School Italian Sandwich Shop only accepts cash.

Four Square/Old School Italian Sandwich Shop

Facebook/Old School Italian Sandwich Shop

FourSquare/Thomas R.

Click here for the official website of Old School Italian Sandwich Shop. Or, go here for Facebook.

OnlyInYourState may earn compensation through affiliate links in this article.

Address: 609 E. 9th Ave., Homestead, PA 15120