Let us ask you a serious question: in all of the times you have crossed the New River Gorge Bridge, how many times have you pulled off of U.S. Route 19 in Fayetteville onto WV-16, a.k.a. S Court Street? (And pulling into Tudor’s on the corner there isn’t exactly what we mean, mind you – although everyone knows Tudor’s is awesome). No, we’re asking if you’ve gone past Tudor’s and into downtown Fayetteville? If you keep rambling past that tried and true Tudor’s on the corner, you’ll eventually arrive at a charming little book store eatery that’s been the heart of Fayetteville for more than 20 years.

Once you experience the Cathedral Cafe and Book Store, you’ll forever change the way you cross the New River Gorge Bridge — because it will be hard to do so without a nagging notion to stop here just one more time.

TripAdvisor/bdaygirl

Whether you’re seeking coffee (in any and every form), breakfast, lunch, or dinner, Cathedral Cafe is a must when you’re in or near Fayetteville.

TripAdvisor/KellyM

Planning a hiking adventure down into the gorge? Celebrate the occasion with one of these.

Google Maps/Catherdreal Cafe & Book Store

The menu at Cathedral Cafe and Book Store is nearly as eclectic as the venue itself.

TripAdvisor/needa123

Once a bona fide house of worship, the former church retains much of the same vibe as in its previous existence. Huge bookshelves are flanked by the even larger ornate windows that filter in colorful light all day long.

Google Maps/Kushalappa Kaliyanda Poonacha

If you’re like us, you’ll go wild over the appetizers, quesadillas, paninis, salads, specials and more… but trust us: save room for dessert! The entire dessert selection is positively heavenly.

Google Maps/Catherdreal Cafe & Book Store

As many times as you may have crossed the New River Gorge Bridge, you may find it difficult to believe how many times you’ve driven by this little gem. It’s only 2.7 miles from the New River Gorge Visitor center on the other side of the bridge!

Facebook/Cathedral Cafe 134 S Court Street Fayetteville, WV

Ready to check it out? Come hungry!

Google Maps

Here’s a map to illustrate just how easy it is to pop off of Route 19 and over to the this amazing eatery and book store.

Google Maps

Cathedral Cafe and Book Store is located at 134 S Court St., Fayetteville, WV 25840. It’s open seven days a week (thank goodness!). The hours are: Monday and Tuesday from 8:00 a.m. to 4:00 p.m., Wednesday through Friday from 8:00 a.m. to 9:00 p.m., Saturday from 7:30 a.m. to 9:00 p.m., and Sunday from 7:30 a.m. to 4:00 p.m. Learn more from their official Facebook page!

TripAdvisor/bdaygirl

TripAdvisor/KellyM

Google Maps/Catherdreal Cafe & Book Store

TripAdvisor/needa123

Google Maps/Kushalappa Kaliyanda Poonacha

Facebook/Cathedral Cafe 134 S Court Street Fayetteville, WV

Google Maps

OnlyInYourState may earn compensation through affiliate links in this article.